KEEN Targhee III vs Merrell MOAB 2 – What you need to know about the Duo

1. Comfort:

KEEN Targhee III: With its spacious toe box and ample cushioning, the Targhee III is praised for its out-of-the-box comfort. The supportive midsole and contoured footbed provide excellent arch support, making it a favorite for long days on the trail.

Merrell MOAB 2: Similarly, the MOAB 2 is lauded for its comfort, featuring a well-cushioned midsole and supportive insole. The fit is snug without feeling restrictive, and many hikers appreciate its immediate comfort without the need for a break-in period.

Winner: It’s a tie. Both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 excel in the comfort department, offering plush cushioning and support for all-day wear.

2. Durability:

KEEN Targhee III: Known for its rugged construction, the Targhee III features a waterproof leather upper and a sturdy rubber toe cap for added protection against rocky terrain. The outsole offers reliable traction on various surfaces, and many users report that these boots hold up well over time.

Merrell MOAB 2: The MOAB 2 also boasts impressive durability, thanks to its durable suede leather and mesh upper. Reinforced with a rubber toe cap and a Vibram outsole, these boots are built to withstand rough conditions and provide dependable traction on challenging trails.

Winner: It’s a close call, but the KEEN Targhee III edges slightly ahead in terms of durability, particularly with its robust leather construction.

3. Breathability:

KEEN Targhee III: While the Targhee III offers decent breathability, some users find that it can trap heat during warmer weather or intense activity. However, the waterproof membrane does a good job of keeping feet dry in wet conditions.

Merrell MOAB 2: The MOAB 2 excels in breathability, thanks to its mesh panels that allow for ample airflow. This makes it a popular choice for hiking in hot climates or during the summer months.

Winner: The Merrell MOAB 2 takes the lead in breathability, providing superior airflow to keep your feet cool and comfortable.

Which one is right for you

Both the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 are excellent hiking shoes that cater to different preferences and needs. If you prioritize durability and support, the Targhee III might be the better option for you. On the other hand, if breathability and versatility are your top concerns, the MOAB 2 could be the perfect fit. Ultimately, the choice comes down to personal preference and the specific demands of your hiking adventures.

4. Waterproofing:

KEEN Targhee III: The Targhee III is equipped with KEEN.DRY technology, providing reliable waterproofing to keep your feet dry in wet conditions. Many users appreciate this feature for hiking in rainy or muddy environments, as it helps prevent water from seeping into the boots.

Merrell MOAB 2: While the MOAB 2 is available in waterproof versions, it’s important to note that not all models come with waterproofing. For those seeking waterproofing, the MOAB 2 WP (waterproof) variant offers a breathable membrane to keep water out while allowing moisture to escape.

Winner: The KEEN Targhee III wins in this category for its consistent waterproofing across all versions, providing peace of mind in wet conditions.

5. Weight:

KEEN Targhee III: The Targhee III is slightly heavier compared to the MOAB 2, which may be a consideration for those who prioritize lightweight footwear. While the added weight contributes to its durability and support, some hikers prefer a lighter option for increased agility on the trail.

Merrell MOAB 2: The MOAB 2 is known for its lightweight design, making it a popular choice among hikers looking for agility and freedom of movement. The lighter weight can be advantageous for long-distance hikes or activities that require speed and flexibility.

Winner: The Merrell MOAB 2 takes the lead in this category for its lighter weight, offering enhanced maneuverability and comfort during extended outings.

If you prioritize waterproofing, durability, and support, the Targhee III may be the better choice. Alternatively, if breathability, lightweight design, and versatility are your main considerations, the MOAB 2 could be the ideal option for your outdoor adventures. weigh the features that matter most to you and select the hiking shoe that aligns with your specific needs and preferences.

6. Stability:

KEEN Targhee III: With its supportive midsole and wide platform, the Targhee III offers excellent stability on uneven terrain. The reinforced heel and ankle support help prevent ankle rolling, providing confidence and security with each step.

Merrell MOAB 2: The MOAB 2 is also praised for its stability, thanks to features like the molded nylon arch shank and air cushion in the heel. These components work together to provide a stable base, reducing fatigue and discomfort on long hikes.

Winner: It’s a tie. Both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 offer commendable stability, allowing hikers to navigate challenging trails with confidence.

7. Price:

KEEN Targhee III: The Targhee III is typically priced in the mid to high range for hiking footwear, reflecting its durable construction and premium features. While it may be a bit more expensive upfront, many users find that the investment pays off in terms of longevity and performance.

Merrell MOAB 2: The MOAB 2 is often priced more affordably compared to the Targhee III, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious hikers. Despite its lower price point, it still delivers solid performance and durability, making it a popular choice among outdoor enthusiasts.

Winner: The Merrell MOAB 2 wins in this category for its competitive pricing, offering excellent value for the features and performance it provides.

While the Targhee III excels in waterproofing, durability, and support, the MOAB 2 shines in breathability, lightweight design, and affordability. Your choice between the two will ultimately depend on your individual preferences, priorities, and budget.

8. Terrain Compatibility:

KEEN Targhee III: The Targhee III is well-suited for a variety of terrains, including rocky trails, muddy paths, and rugged terrain. Its aggressive outsole provides excellent traction on both wet and dry surfaces, making it a reliable companion for challenging hikes.

Merrell MOAB 2: Similarly, the MOAB 2 is designed to tackle various terrains with ease. Its Vibram outsole offers superior grip and stability, allowing you to confidently navigate steep ascents, descents, and uneven terrain.

Winner: It’s a tie. Both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 are versatile enough to handle a wide range of terrains, ensuring that you stay sure-footed and comfortable regardless of the conditions.

9. Style:

KEEN Targhee III: The Targhee III boasts a rugged and outdoorsy aesthetic, with its leather upper and durable construction. It’s available in a range of color options to suit different tastes and preferences, making it a stylish choice for hiking and everyday wear.

Merrell MOAB 2: The MOAB 2 features a sleek and sporty design, with mesh panels for added breathability and a modern silhouette. It also comes in various colorways to appeal to different style preferences, allowing you to express your personality on the trail.

Winner: This category is subjective, as it depends on individual style preferences. Both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 offer stylish options that blend form and function seamlessly.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 are both outstanding choices for hiking footwear, each offering unique features and advantages. Whether you prioritize waterproofing, durability, support, breathability, affordability, or style, there’s a shoe that meets your needs. Ultimately, your decision should be based on your specific preferences, intended use, and the demands of your hiking adventures. No matter which option you choose, you can trust that both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 will provide the comfort, performance, and reliability you need to conquer the trails with confidence.

Here are some frequently asked questions (FAQs) about the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 hiking shoes:

Q1: Are the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 true to size?

A1: Both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 generally run true to size for most wearers. However, it’s always recommended to try them on or refer to the manufacturer’s sizing guide for the best fit.

Q2: Can I use the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 for backpacking trips?

A2: Yes, both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 are suitable for backpacking trips, thanks to their supportive construction, durable materials, and reliable traction. However, it’s essential to consider factors such as pack weight, trail conditions, and personal comfort preferences when choosing hiking footwear for backpacking.

Q3: Do the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 require a break-in period?

A3: While both shoes are known for their comfort out of the box, some users may find that they benefit from a short break-in period to allow the materials to conform to their feet. It’s recommended to wear them around the house or on shorter hikes before embarking on longer treks to ensure optimal comfort and fit.

Q4: Are the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 suitable for wide feet?

A4: Yes, both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 are available in wide sizes, making them suitable options for individuals with wider feet. These wide versions offer additional room in the toe box and midfoot area for a more accommodating fit.

Q5: Can I use the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 for trail running?

A5: While both shoes are designed primarily for hiking and backpacking, some users may find them suitable for light trail running or fast-paced hikes. However, it’s essential to consider your specific running style, foot mechanics, and terrain conditions before using them for running activities. For dedicated trail running, it’s recommended to choose footwear specifically designed for that purpose.

Q6: Are the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 suitable for use in cold weather or winter conditions?

A6: While both shoes provide excellent traction and durability, they may not offer sufficient insulation for extremely cold or snowy conditions. However, you can enhance their warmth by wearing thick socks or adding insulated insoles. For prolonged exposure to cold weather or winter hiking, consider using insulated boots specifically designed for those conditions.

Q7: Can I resole the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 when the outsoles wear out?

A7: It’s typically possible to resole hiking shoes like the Targhee III and the MOAB 2, although it may vary depending on the specific construction of the shoe and the availability of replacement outsoles. It’s best to contact the manufacturer or a reputable cobbler to inquire about resoling options for your particular model.

Q8: Do the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 offer good arch support for individuals with flat feet or high arches?

A8: Both shoes are designed with supportive midsoles and contoured footbeds that provide adequate arch support for most users. However, individuals with specific foot conditions may benefit from custom orthotics or insoles to address their unique support needs. It’s essential to try on the shoes and assess their comfort and support levels based on your individual foot shape and arch height.

Q9: Are the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 vegan-friendly?

A9: While both brands offer some vegan-friendly footwear options, the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 may contain materials such as leather or suede in their construction. If you’re looking for vegan alternatives, it’s recommended to check the product descriptions or contact the manufacturers directly to inquire about vegan options within their product lines.

Q10: Can I use the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 for water activities such as kayaking or river trekking?

A10: While both shoes offer waterproofing and durable construction, they are primarily designed for hiking and may not provide the necessary drainage or quick-drying properties for water activities. For water-specific activities, it’s best to choose footwear specifically designed for water sports, such as water shoes or amphibious sandals, to ensure optimal performance and comfort in wet environments.

Q11: How do I clean and maintain the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 hiking shoes?

A11: Cleaning and maintaining your hiking shoes can prolong their lifespan and performance. Here’s a general guide:

• Remove excess dirt and debris by gently brushing the shoes with a soft-bristled brush or cloth.
• For light cleaning, use a mild soap or detergent mixed with water to spot clean stains or dirt buildup. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaners.
• Rinse the shoes thoroughly with clean water to remove any soap residue.
• Allow the shoes to air dry naturally, away from direct heat sources like radiators or sunlight, which can cause damage to the materials.
• Once dry, apply a waterproofing treatment or conditioner suitable for the shoe’s materials to restore water repellency and maintain durability.
• Periodically check and tighten laces, seams, and stitching to ensure structural integrity and prevent premature wear and tear.

Q12: Can I use aftermarket insoles with the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 for additional cushioning or support?

A12: Yes, you can use aftermarket insoles with both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 to customize the cushioning and support levels according to your preferences and foot needs. However, it’s essential to choose insoles that are compatible with the shoe’s design and offer the right level of arch support and cushioning for your feet.

Q13: Are the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 suitable for use on paved or urban trails?

A13: While both shoes are primarily designed for hiking and outdoor use, they can also be worn on paved or urban trails with relatively flat terrain. However, their aggressive tread patterns and rugged construction may feel less comfortable and efficient compared to lightweight sneakers or walking shoes designed specifically for urban environments.

Q14: Can I use the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 for light scrambling or off-trail hiking?

A14: Yes, both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 are suitable for light scrambling and off-trail hiking, thanks to their durable construction, supportive midsoles, and grippy outsoles. However, it’s essential to exercise caution and assess the terrain carefully, as they may not provide the same level of stability and protection as dedicated approach shoes or hiking boots with higher ankle support.

Q15: How do I know when it’s time to replace my KEEN Targhee III or Merrell MOAB 2 hiking shoes?

A15: Signs that indicate it’s time to replace your hiking shoes include visible wear and tear on the outsole, significant loss of tread depth or traction, noticeable compression or breakdown of the midsole cushioning, and visible damage to the upper materials such as tears or delamination. Additionally, if you experience discomfort, pain, or lack of support while wearing the shoes, it may be a sign that they no longer provide adequate protection and should be replaced.

This table provides you with a concise comparison of the key features of the KEEN Targhee III and the Merrell MOAB 2 hiking shoes, helping you evaluate their differences and choose the option that best meets your needs and preferences.

In the end, whether you opt for the KEEN Targhee III or the Merrell MOAB 2, both hiking shoes offer exceptional performance, comfort, and durability to enhance your outdoor adventures. Consider your specific priorities, such as waterproofing, breathability, stability, and budget, to make the best choice for your hiking needs. No matter which option you choose, rest assured that both the Targhee III and the MOAB 2 will provide the support and reliability you need to conquer the trails with confidence. So lace up your shoes, hit the trails, and enjoy the great outdoors to the fullest!